|
情景4：非正式谈判达成协议或解决方案的实施 - 将协商民主应用于实践
Scenario 4: Implementation of Informally Negotiated Agreements or Settlements - Applying Deliberative Democracy to Practice |
|
| |
| 课程网址: |
http://videolectures.net/mit11969s05_yankelovich_lec05/
|
| 主讲教师: |
Joshua Cohen, Susan Sherry, Daniel Yankelovich
|
| 开课单位: |
麻省理工学院
|
| 开课时间: |
2012-04-24
|
| 课程语种: |
英语
|
| 中文简介: |
让当地居民参与监督“棕地重建”计划的社区努力正在结束。将根据通过调解对话达成的清理协议，分配联邦和州的资金以及大量私人投资，以帮助清理被遗弃的污染场地。该计划回答了“如何清洁干净？”的问题，并阐明拟在现场开发的新住房，商业和娱乐设施的设计。在可信的冲突评估之前建立共识的过程产生了更多的书面共识。这个过程中有30多名参与者。然而，在小组向市议会提出最终建议之前，一个新的社区组织似乎声称它被排除在外，它曾试图说服咨询小组修改其提案，但没有成功，它正在征求市议会的承诺，即咨询小组的提议不会被接受。重点是建立共识承诺的合法性以及合法性可能建立或正确竞争的条件。如果相关机构给予默许批准过程（以及指定的技术人员参加），在什么基础上可以或应该忽略共识发展通过一个完全透明的过程多月？对提议的计划进行不具约束力的公投会“解决”这个问题吗？
|
| 课程简介: |
A neighborhood effort to involve local residents in overseeing a "brownfields redevelopment" program is just wrapping up. Federal and state funds, as well as substantial private investment, will be allocated to help clean up an abandoned contaminated site based on the clean-up agreement reached through a mediated dialogue. The plan answers the question “How clean is clean?" and spells out the proposed design of new housing, commercial and recreational facilities to be developed on the site. A consensus building process -- preceded by a credible conflict assessment -- generated a written consensus among the more than 30 participants in the process. Right before the group presents its final recommendations to the city council, however, a new neighborhood group appears claiming that it has been left out, that it had tried unsuccessfully to convince the advisory group to modify its proposals, and it is seeking a promise from the city council that the advisory group's proposal will not be accepted. The focus is on the legitimacy of consensus building promises and the conditions under which that legitimacy might be established or rightly contested. If the relevant agency gave tacit approval to the process (and assigned technical staff to attend), on what basis can it or should it ignore the consensus developed over many months through a completely transparent process? Would a non-binding referendum on the proposed plan “solve” this problem?
|
| 关 键 词: |
调解对话; 共识承诺; 协商民主
|
| 课程来源: |
视频讲座网
|
| 最后编审: |
2019-05-19：yuh
|
| 阅读次数: |
75
|
|
图 书 馆