0


9 月 11 日与城市 / 城市创伤和城市的复原力

September 11th and the City / Urban Trauma and the Resilience of Cities
课程网址: http://videolectures.net/mitworld_campanella_vale_scut/  
主讲教师: Thomas J. Campanella; Lawrence J. Vale
开课单位: 麻省理工学院
开课时间: 2011-02-28
课程语种: 英语
中文简介:
9月11日和城市 拉尔夫·沃尔多·爱默生曾写道:“对文明的考验是从城市中获取最大利益的力量。” 因此,恐怖主义的考验很可能是对这些文化、商业和交流中心造成最大伤害的力量。9月11日的恐怖分子对此深有体会。穆罕默德·阿塔 (Mohamed Atta) 深谙城市的力量和威严,想必也深知它们的耐用性和复原力。他接受过工程师、建筑师和城市规划师培训。然而,在原教旨主义的扭曲下,阿塔成为了 EB 怀特几十年前在《这里是纽约》中想象的“变态梦想家”,一个将在曼哈顿“释放闪电”并试图从象征意义上和字面上摧毁它的人。尽管世贸中心的废墟在 9 月 11 日之后的几天和几周内闷烧,美国的专家们也预言了市中心的死亡和我们所知道的城市的终结。但数千年来,城市遭受了创伤和暴力,其中大部分比 9 月 11 日穆罕默德·阿塔 (Mohamed Atta) 发动的暴力还要严重。任何对这座城市历史的研究都将揭示,人类住区拥有在遭受破坏后自我复兴的基本能力,弹性城市研讨会希望重申这一点。 城市创伤和城市的复原力 本文通过分析创伤、恢复和记忆的概念,探讨了几乎无处不在的城市复原力。它通过探索建筑环境的恢复与其他可以衡量“恢复正常”的方式之间的关系,对“复原力”的定义提出了质疑。城市创伤,就像城市复原力一样,有多种形式,并且可以通过多种方式进行分类。首先,破坏的规模可能从一个小的单一区域到整个城市(或者可能是更大的区域)。其次,人们可以根据造成的人员伤亡对这些创伤进行排名,以死亡和生活中断来衡量。第三,人们可以根据推测的原因来组织这些破坏性行为——有些是由于基本上无法控制的自然力量造成的,例如地震和洪水;有些是由于自然力量造成的。其他则是自然力量和人类行为的混合体,例如火灾;还有一些行为则更完全是人类故意造成的,无论是通过征服军队、空中轰炸还是恐怖袭击来执行的。仅仅提出有关城市复兴的一般性问题是不够的;我们必须问谁恢复了城市的哪些方面以及通过什么机制。灾后恢复过程是了解受灾社会权力结构的一个窗口。同样,询问记忆就是询问记忆是如何、何时、由谁构建的。我们必须问谁恢复了城市的哪些方面以及通过什么机制。灾后恢复过程是了解受灾社会权力结构的一个窗口。同样,询问记忆就是询问记忆是如何、何时、由谁构建的。我们必须问谁恢复了城市的哪些方面以及通过什么机制。灾后恢复过程是了解受灾社会权力结构的一个窗口。同样,询问记忆就是询问记忆是如何、何时、由谁构建的。
课程简介: September 11th and the City Ralph Waldo Emerson once wrote "The test of civilization is the power of drawing the most benefit out of cities." The test of terrorism, then, may well be the power to inflict the greatest harm to those same centers of culture, commerce, and exchange. This is something that the September 11 terrorists well understood. Mohamed Atta was a man well acquainted with the power and majesty of cities--and presumably their durability and resilience. He was trained as an engineer, architect and urban planner. Yet, warped by fundamentalism, Atta became the "perverted dreamer" that E. B. White imagined decades ago in Here is New York, a man who would "loose the lightning" on Manhattan and attempt to destroy it, symbolically and literally. And even as the rubble of the World Trade Center smoldered in the days and weeks following September 11, pundits in the United States, too, foretold of the death of downtown and the end of the city as we know it. But cities have endured trauma and violence for millennia, much of it far worse than that unleashed by Mohamed Atta on September 11. Any study of the city in history will reveal that human settlements possess an essential ability to resurrect themselves in the wake of devastation, a point that the Resilient City colloquium hopes to reaffirm. Urban Trauma and the Resilience of Cities This paper examines the near-ubiquity of urban resilience by analyzing the concepts of trauma, recovery, and remembrance. It questions the definition of "resilience," by exploring the relationship between recovery of the built environment and other ways that a "return to normalcy" may be measured. Urban trauma, like urban resilience, takes many forms, and can be categorized in many ways. First, there is the scale of destruction-which may range from a small single precinct to an entire city (or, potentially, an even larger area). Second, one may rank these traumas in terms of their human toll, as measured by deaths and disruption of lives. Third, one may organize these destructive acts according to their presumed cause-some result from the largely-uncontrollable forces of nature, such as earthquakes and floods; others are hybrids of natural forces and human action, such as fires; while still others result more wholly from deliberate human will, whether executed by conquering armies, aerial bombardment, or terrorist strikes. It is not enough to ask general questions about urban recovery; we must ask who recovers which aspects of the city, and by what mechanisms. The process of post-disaster recovery is a window into the power structure of the society that has been stricken. Similarly, to ask about remembrance is to inquire how what is remembered gets constructed, when, and by whom.
关 键 词: 城市创伤; 城市复原力; 韧性城市
课程来源: 视频讲座网
数据采集: 2023-11-14:wujk
最后编审: 2023-11-14:wujk
阅读次数: 14