0


犯罪、冲突和刑法的种族主义

Crime, Conflict and the Racialization of Criminal Law
课程网址: http://videolectures.net/esc09_fagan_ccr/  
主讲教师: Jeffrey Fagan
开课单位: 哥伦比亚大学
开课时间: 2009-10-30
课程语种: 英语
中文简介:
20世纪60年代末美国47个城市发生骚乱的伤痕至今仍然明显, 不仅在少数顽固贫穷城市的物质景观中如此, 在刑法的哲学和判例中也能看到。刑事司法系统。骚乱发生在美国城市进行深刻的社会和经济结构调整的过程中, 在犯罪率和混乱率上升的流行开始时, 这既构成了美国新的政治秩序, 也构成了美国的深刻变革刑法和刑事诉讼程序。在这十年中, 种族和文化冲突 – 推动的政治和法律动员 – 导致刑法的实质和哲学突然逆转。上世纪 6 0年代初, 刑事被告的权利被剥夺, 警察监管力度不断加大, 通过一系列连锁的法院判决和新的法律, 建立了一个惩罚制度, 在过去的三十年里, 惩罚制度扩大了警察的权威, 限制了刑事被告的程序性权利, 并支持维持监禁方面日益扩大的种族差距的政策。一套新的刑法虽然表面上与种族无关, 但也产生了深远的种族后果, 即使在低犯罪率时代也是持久和可持续的。本文第一部分论述了刑法这一转变的前因、背景和动态, 重点讨论了在骚乱浪潮中爆发的种族动态。第二部分考察了新法律秩序的发展, 通过二十年来的一系列法院裁决分析了法律的逆转。第三部分审查了在没有补充的社会监管模式的情况下利用种族中立的法律来实现犯罪控制如何产生不同的种族影响, 这些影响已成为政治秩序的内生。第四部分讨论了恢复刑事司法中种族平等的法律和体制改革所面临的挑战。美国的经验是一个警示性的故事, 刑法的限制和危险, 以管理多样性和社会冲突。
课程简介: The scars from riots in 47 American cities in the late 1960s remain visible today not only in the physical landscape of a few stubbornly poor cities, but in a philosophy and jurisprudence of criminal law that has instantiated the disparate fates of racial minorities in the criminal justice system. The riots took place in the midst of profound social and economic restructuring of the nation’s cities, and at the outset of an epidemic of rising rates of crime and disorder that framed both a new political order and a profound transformation of American criminal law and criminal procedure. Within the decade, a political and legal mobilization – fueled by racial and cultural conflict – led to an abrupt reversal in the substance and philosophy of criminal law. The ceding of rights to criminal defendants and the increasing regulation of police in the early 1960s gave way through a series of cascading court decisions and new laws to a punitive regime that, over three decades, has expanded the authority of police, curtailed the procedural rights of criminal defendants, and supported policies that have sustained a widening racial gap in incarceration. A new body of criminal laws, though facially race-neutral, have had profound racial consequences that are durable and sustainable even in a low crime era. Part I of this paper discusses the antecedents, contexts and dynamics of this turn in criminal law, focusing on the racial dynamics that exploded in a wave of riots. Part II examines the development of the new legal order, analyzing the reversal in law through a series of court decisions over two decades. Part III examines how the use of race-neutral laws to achieve crime control in the absence of complementary models of social regulation has produced disparate racial impacts that have become endogenous to the political order. Part IV discusses the challenges to legal and institutional reform to restore racial equality in criminal justice. The American experience is a cautionary tale of the limits and dangers of criminal law to manage diversity and social conflict.
关 键 词: 人权; 社会; 犯罪
课程来源: 视频讲座网
最后编审: 2020-06-06:毛岱琦(课程编辑志愿者)
阅读次数: 59